What makes economics economics?
In Jonathan Stern's guest column, "The failure of the department of Economics, Stern broadly criticizes Duke Economics for failing to introduce to undergraduates “the history and philosophy of economics.” Frankly, I consider this approach—and any mandatory introduction to economic history and philosophy without formal training in theory and empirical techniques—a bad idea. Not only do I think that undergraduate economics education should not begin with so-called “Great Books," I think that they should not be a mandatory component of an undergraduate (or graduate, for that matter) education at all.